Penelope Kay and her friend Selena Imai are doing a whipped cream taste test. The girls know that Selena's stepbrother Ricky Spanish is watching them, so they invite him to do a blindfolded taste test. They include their own pussy cream in the taste test, and he can't decide which of theirs taste the best, but he likes them better than the whipped cream.The girls need to know whose is better, so they dress in matching lingerie and create a double pussy stack for Ricky to taste. He obediently eats first Selina and then Penelope out. He still can't decide, so he pulls his dick out and tries first Penelope and then Selina, still blindfolded. Since Ricky guesses correctly which girl is which, he gets to fuck Selina first.As Selina enjoys Ricky's stiffie from behind, she laps at Penelope's big naturals and then her twat. Then the girls swap spots so Penelope can be in the middle of a stepsibling sandwich. Selina hops on the counter so Penelope can cradle her as Ricky does her. Then the girls each roll onto their sides so Ricky has a coochie buffet to pound. They end their fuck fest on their knees with Ricky splashing each of their faces with his cum shot, giving them the winner of the pie topping contest.
